| Annie Horton |
| Annie Horton | |
| B: | 1841 |
| Fordham , Village of West Farms, Westchester County, New York | |
| Catharine Horton |
| Catharine Horton | |
| B: | Abt 1842 |
| Fordham , Village of West Farms, Westchester County, New York | |
| Henry Underhill |
| Henry Underhill | |
| B: | 1838 |
| New York | |
| D: | 1874 |
| New York | |
| Benjamin Underhill Horton |
| Benjamin Underhill Horton | |
| B: | 1805 |
| Westchester County, New York | |
| D: | 1868 |
| West Farms, Westchester County, New York | |
| Unknown |
| Nancy J. Underhill |
| Nancy J. Underhill | |
| B: | 1812 |
| M: | Aft 1860 |
| D: | 1874 |