| Father | Male Benjamin Underhill Horton |
| Born | 1805 | Westchester County, New York |
| Died | 1868 | West Farms, Westchester County, New York |
| Buried | ||
| Married | 4 May 1835 | Dutch Reformed Church, Fordham, Bronx, New York |
| Other Spouse | Living | F0266 | |
| Married | ||
| Other Spouse | Nancy J. Underhill | F0267 | |
| Married | Aft 1860 | |
| Father | Living | F0265 Group Sheet | |
| Mother | Living | F0265 Group Sheet | |
| Child 1 | Female Annie Horton |
| Born | 1841 | Fordham , Village of West Farms, Westchester County, New York |
| Died | ||
| Buried |
| Child 2 | Female Catharine Horton |
| Born | Abt 1842 | Fordham , Village of West Farms, Westchester County, New York |
| Died | ||
| Buried | ||
| Spouse | Henry Underhill | F0268 | |
| Married | ||